

Ultimately, these affairs paint a picture of a game and a scene where playing well and doing your best in the confines of the rules won’t get you where you deserve to be, and where human error and thoughtless decisions repeatedly diminish the competitive integrity of the game. But the individual big-ticket tournaments all came down to something unlikely-and you can’t have decisive series come down to Ragnaros Hero Power coin flips like this, where the players kept on trying to hit the right target with their ability to deal eight damage to a random enemy over and over again. The ladder provided a reasonable way to determine long-term excellence (though the final-day dashes for qualification spots were still variance-ridden affairs if also great streaming content). But just consider poker for a second and the fact that there is now an entire game theory optimal approach all mathed out, and it would be ludicrous to say that the small percentages picked up by better players along the way don’t add up to something tangible in the long run. That is not the same as saying that there is no skill involved whatsoever, and the fact that anyone can beat anyone in a single encounter is a large part of the appeal of games like this.

The skill-testing element of card games only shines through across a large sample of games due to their inherent variance. If you look at the stats on, the game boasts the eleventh-largest cumulative prize pool with $29.4 million distributed to almost 3,000 players across more than 1,000 tournaments, still ahead of Rocket League, Apex Legends, and VALORANT at the time of writing. People don’t necessarily realize just how big Hearthstone’s esports scene got over the years.

In 2014, Hearthstone was an exquisite-looking title with AAA production levels and a juggernaut in the then-nascent digital card game scene, importing predatory monetization schemes from tabletop titles without backlash while Wizards of the Coast was still floundering away with MTG Online to rake in eye-popping profits. Ten years is an eternity in the gaming industry, and the fact that Hearthstone has maintained a competitive scene for this long is a testament to the game’s success, even as the global gaming market and the role of collectible games therein continued to shift.
